THE KITCHEN GARDEN LEDGER
🍂 Notes from the growing season · Fall edition
SOIL · FALL NOTES

Everyone plants copper beside their tomatoes in May. A 36-year market gardener on why that's the wrong month.

The copper doesn't work on the plant. It works on the ground. And the ground is there all winter.

⚠️ If you already own one, or you're about to, read this before you push it in.
Ruth Keller
Ruth KellerGrew vegetables for market for 36 years
A gardener pressing a copper antenna into a bare raised bed in October

Bed three, last Saturday morning. Thirty seconds, and I won't touch it again until May.

It was 7:40 on Saturday morning and the hose was stiff.

Frost on the grass. The tomato stems in bed three cut down to stubs. The whole bed bare and dark and finished for the year.

I took a piece of copper about the length of my forearm, pushed it four inches into the soil, and walked back inside for my coffee.

That's it. That's the whole job. I won't touch that bed again until May.

My neighbour watched me do it over the fence. “Ruth, the season's over.”

I know it is. That's exactly why I do it now.

Every spring, another bag.

For thirty-six years I grew vegetables for market. Eleven beds at the peak. Tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, greens. I know what a bed is supposed to do.

And for the last ten of those years, mine stopped doing it.

March: the trip to the farm store. The same bags. The blue powder. The spreader.

May: everything looks wonderful. June: it goes flat. Pale leaves, thin stems, half the fruit I used to get. By the middle of June I'm bending low over those beds with another bag, and by July I've stopped looking at them.

Everyone had the same answer for me. “Your dirt's given out, Ruth. It's worn out. Feed it more.”

A garden shed shelf crowded with half-used fertilizer bags

My shed, this time last year. Count the bags.

What I tried before the copper.

If my soil was really worn out, the test would have said so. It didn't say so. Because it wasn't.

Your soil was never empty. It was asleep.

Here is what finally made sense of it for me.

A spoonful of garden soil is full of minerals. Potassium, calcium, magnesium, iron. The things your tomatoes are made of. They're in the grit, in the clay, in every bed in your yard. They're down there, lying quiet, lying deep.

The trouble was never that the minerals were gone. The trouble is that a plant can't use a mineral that's locked up. It has to be loosened, moved and taken up by the root. And that work only happens when the soil is awake and busy.

Think of a pantry with the door stuck. The food's all there. Nobody can get to it.

A bag of fertilizer is takeout. It hands the plant a hot meal through the window, fast. Three weeks later the meal is gone, the pantry door is still stuck, and you're ordering again. That's the loop. That's where the money goes.

So the question I'd been asking for ten years was wrong. Not “what do I add?” It's “what wakes it up?”

A charge in the air. A piece of copper to bring it down.

The air above your garden carries a small, natural electrical charge. Always. On a clear day it's there, you just can't feel it.

Copper carries electricity better than any metal on earth except silver. It's why every wire in your house is copper.

That's the whole idea, and it's a hundred years old. A coil of copper at the top catches a little of that charge. A solid copper rod carries it four inches down into the ground, right where the minerals are sleeping. The way the old growers explained it, that small steady charge is what the soil life and the root tips need to get busy again.

I'm not a scientist. I'm a grower. So I did what growers do when someone tells them something: one bed with, one bed without. Same seed, same water, same sun. I'll show you what came up in a minute.

Put the copper in the ground, four inches, and you're done. No mixing. No truck. It doesn't rust, it doesn't run out, and it doesn't want a thing from you.
SEE WHAT I PUT IN THE GROUND
60 days to change your mind · Free shipping

Why October, and not May.

This is the part nobody tells you, and it's the part that matters most.

The copper doesn't work on the plant. It works on the ground. And the ground is there all winter.

Everyone I know who tries one of these pushes it in next to a tomato in May and waits. That's fine. By all accounts it works that way too. But think about what you're asking of it. A bed that's been asleep for ten years, woken up on the same morning you ask it to feed a hungry plant.

I'd rather wake it up in October and let it have the winter.

  1. The ground is still soft.You can push a copper rod into October soil in thirty seconds. Try that in January. Get one in before the ground goes hard.
  2. Nothing else is going on.Spring is the busiest week of the year. In October I've got nothing to do but put the hose away.
  3. The second season beats the first.That's what the gardeners who use these keep writing, and it's what I saw. So I give the bed a head start. By the time my tomatoes go in, the copper has been in the ground seven months. The bed is already awake.
A copper antenna standing in a raised bed under snow

January. It's doing nothing you can see. That's normal. It isn't there for you to see.

A Frenchman drew it up. Then the bags came.

This is not a TikTok invention. Curious growers have been planting metal in their soil for 240 years.

1749

Abbé Nollet, France. Reports that electricity seemed to speed up plant growth.

1783

Abbé Bertholon plants a tall metal pole to gather charge from the air for his crops. The great-grandfather of the piece of copper in my bed.

1904

Selim Lemström, Finland. Notices crops near the Arctic grow fast under the northern lights, and strings wires over his own fields.

1920s

Justin Christofleau, France. A baker's-equipment inventor turned garden man. Builds copper antennas for farms and vineyards west of Paris. Farmers run them from 1922 to 1927. He writes a book called Electroculture.

1939

The war comes and his factory closes. After the war, fertilizer comes in a bag, and the bag is easy.

And a bag has something a piece of copper will never have: it runs out. There's no money in a piece of copper that's still out there working when you're gone.

So nobody sold it to you. That's all. The method didn't fail. It just stopped being sold.

What's in my beds now.

I'll be straight with you: the first ones I bought were a six-pack off Amazon. A wooden dowel with thin copper wire wrapped round it. One winter in a wet bed and the wood went soft and the wire slid off. The only copper in the thing was the wire.

The one I use now is solid copper from end to end. An 8 mm copper rod, with 4 mm copper wire wound round it by hand into a tight coil at the top. No wood. No plating. Lab-checked at 99.9% copper. It stands about a foot above the soil and weighs about four ounces, which is more than it looks.

It won't rot and it won't rust. It goes dark bronze over a winter, then slowly green over the years. That's how you know it's real copper, and it's rather handsome in a bed.

It's hand-wound in a small workshop and every batch is numbered on a card in the box. The box has a planting guide in it, and a copy of Christofleau's original book, which I did not expect and read in one sitting.

The one I use is linked below. I don't know how long this batch lasts. The last time I ordered, the pack I wanted was gone for three weeks.

The solid copper antenna, rod to hand-wound coil

Solid copper, rod to coil. The wood-core kind is what's in my shed bin.

CHECK IF THIS BATCH IS STILL IN
Hand-wound · Batch-numbered · 60-day promise

What came up in June.

Bed three had the copper in it from October. Bed four, right beside it, had nothing. Same soil, same tomato seedlings from the same tray, same hose.

May: no difference. I'll be honest about that. Two beds of little green plants.

The second week of June, when bed four started to go flat the way they all do, bed three didn't. The leaves stayed dark. The stems stayed thick.

By the second week of July the bed-three vines were over the top of the trellis and I was tying them to the fence. Bed four looked like every other year of the last ten.

I did not feed bed three once. Not one bag. My neighbour asked what I was doing differently, and I told him: nothing. I'd done it in October.

Two raised beds side by side in July, the one with the antenna taller and fuller

July 14. Left: copper since October. Right: nothing. Same seed, same water. My garden, not a promise. Results vary.

I'm not the only one.

★★★★★
“The changes in my gardens since including these wonderful tools are mind blowing!!”David S., verified buyer

★★★★★
“I'm really impressed with the rods my garden is doing so better than in previous years. I plan on ordering more.”Simone A., verified buyer

★★★★★
“The result is clear. It works. And to top it all, they're beautiful.”Rebecca L., verified buyer

Rated 4.8 by 2,565+ gardeners.

What happens, month by month.

October

Push it in. Thirty seconds. Forget it.

Winter

Snow on the coil. Nothing to see. That's normal.

April

First bed I could get a trowel into. The copper's gone bronze.

May

Transplants go in. The bed is already awake. No bag.

June, July

Where the other beds go flat, this one keeps going. Vines over the trellis.

Season 2

Better than season one. That's what everyone says, and it's what I'm counting on.

The copper antenna with a bronze patina among April transplants

April. One winter in and it's gone bronze. That's real copper doing what real copper does.

THIS BATCH IS ON THE SHELF · WHILE IT LASTS
The open box: hand-wound copper antennas and the planting guide
🎁 ONE RAISED BED, DONE
BUY 3, GET 2 FREE

Five antennas, hand-wound and batch-numbered. One per ten square feet, about three feet apart, so five does a raised bed or a kitchen garden. The planting guide and Christofleau's book come in the box. Doing the whole garden? There's a buy 6, get 6 free on the next page.

CLAIM THE 5 PACK
Sell-out risk: High | Free shipping | 60 days to change your mind

Put one in a single bed. If it isn't what I described, send it back within 60 days for a full refund. No questions asked.

About the sixty days.

The company gives you sixty days to change your mind, no questions asked. I'll be honest with you, because somebody should be: if you put it in this October, sixty days is December. You won't see a tomato in December.

What you'll see in sixty days is the copper in your hand. Solid, heavy, hand-wound, the real thing. If it isn't that, send it back and they refund you. If it is that, leave it in the ground and let next summer come around.

I can't tell you what it'll do in your bed. I've never seen your ground. Put one in a single bed and find out. That's what I did.

CB
Carol B.Does it have to be in a bed? Everything I grow is in pots on a patio.
3d · Like · Reply · 👍 14 · View 2 replies
RK
Ruth KellerPots are fine, Carol. One does a cluster of big pots. Push it into the biggest one, four inches down.
3d · Like · Reply · 👍 9
DM
Dennis M.Ground's already frozen here in Minnesota. Too late?
2d · Like · Reply · 👍 6
RK
Ruth KellerIf you can't push it in, the bed waits for the thaw. Pots in the garage, or the first soft week in March. Order now, plant then. The copper doesn't mind waiting.
2d · Like · Reply · 👍 11
JW
Jan W.Mine have been in since last fall. I was sure this was another internet gimmick and I only did one bed so my husband wouldn't laugh. That bed is the one he shows people now. Second summer was better than the first, the tomatoes went past the top of the cage and I never opened a bag.
5d · Like · Reply · 👍❤️ 31
PR
Pete R.Bought the Amazon 10 pack last year. Wood rotted, wire slid off by spring. Ordered these.
4d · Like · Reply · 👍 8
AT
Anne T.How many for a 4 by 8 bed?
2d · Like · Reply · 👍 3 · View 1 reply
LS
Linda S.32 square feet so 3 or 4. I put 5 in the one bed about 3 feet apart, that's the buy 3 get 2.
2d · Like · Reply · 👍 7
MD
Marie D.Will it rust?
1d · Like · Reply · 👍 2
RK
Ruth KellerSolid copper can't rust, Marie. It goes bronze over the winter. Mine are three years in and look better every year.
1d · Like · Reply · 👍 5
GH
Gail H.Ordered the 5 pack this morning before the ground goes hard. Thank you Ruth.
6h · Like · Reply · 👍 4

If your beds gave out this year.

You can do what I did for ten years. March, the store, the bag. June, flat. July, another bag.

Or you can take thirty seconds in October and give the bed the winter.

Not more. Not fancier. Just once, and then leave it alone.

A crate of tomatoes and greens on the edge of the bed, the antenna behind

Bed three, end of July. A piece of copper in October and nothing else.

GET ONE IN BEFORE THE GROUND GOES HARD
Buy 3, get 2 free · Free shipping · 60 days to change your mind
UPDATE: Every antenna is wound by hand and the batch on the shelf is numbered. When it's gone there's a wait for the next one, and in most of the country the ground won't wait. If the soil outside your door is still soft, this is the week.